Why Trinamul Congress In West Bengal, India Should be Out of Office After Election?

West Bengal cannot afford another five years of the type of leadership that Mamata Banerjee could provide.  

by N.S.Venkataraman

I am not in politics .  However,  I  am a close political observer for the  last  several years. I try to objectively analyse the  movement of politics and politicians to the best of my ability, without having any prejudice or love or hate for any  political outfit or political philosophy.

In my capacity as chemical engineer,  I was working in a factory in West Bengal several years  back, when Jyoti Basu was the Chief Minister of the state.  Before moving to West Bengal, I worked in a factory in Kerala in a chemical plant.  When I was working in Kerala too , I have seen Marxist government in the state.

I was gheroed in West Bengal for second time, after being gheroed in Kerala for the first time.  Nevertheless, I have not allowed this bitter experience to influence my overall impression about both these states, which have unique and laudable features.

During my working in West Bengal, I became a sincere admirer of Bengalis for variety of positive reasons

I always felt  that if Bengal were to  get a progressive government with national outlook with a knowledgeable and earnest Chief Minister, West Bengal could become one of the most prosperous states in the country.  It has no reason not to be so. Though Jyoti Basu was a highly cultured and civilized person, he could not stop violent and hate politics  in West Bengal  for whatever reasons,  though Jyoti Basu could successfully maintain his image as a decent and respectable person.

Now that Mamata Banerjee has been the Chief Minister of West Bengal for ten years as unquestioned founder leader of Trinamul Congress,  I feel she has not utilized the opportunity to benefit the state to the extent needed , given the massive mandate she has.

During her ten years rule, violent incidents  have  remained unabated in West Bengal and her image and claim that she was a street fighter has not helped the matter.  

I was totally shocked when Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee entered a police station in the state and forced the police to release a worker belonging to her party , who was arrested by the police for some offence.  My immediate feeling was as to how a Chief Minister could do such things and I started wondering as to  whether any other Chief minister has done similar act in any state in India.  I could not find another example. 

Since this untenable act of Mamata Banerjee happened during   the beginning of her first term , I thought she would improve her public conduct and refrain from similar acts in future.   Though Mamata Banerjee did not repeat this obnoxious act, the vituperative language that she was using frequently  , even as Chief Minister of the state, to abuse and criticise the leaders of the opposition parties , created a  violent atmosphere in West Bengal.  She went to the extent  of stating that she would want to slap the Prime Minister Modi.

I am not particularly  impressed  by several of the criticisms made against her such as appeasing minority community, allowing her nephew to interfere in government and party affairs etc.   However, I cannot but note that she has not been able to inculcate a climate  of economic and industrial growth in the state to any significant level.

The ground reality and the fact is that  Mamata Banerjee  was  focusing more in political acts rather than acts   relating to economy and development and her Chief ministership   has been weighing more  towards  political aspects rather than on development and economic aspects. This scenario would become clear to any observer with regard to  economic development registered  in West Bengal during the last ten years.

In short , it has been  noisy West Bengal that she is  leading rather than a dignified  and progressive West Bengal that Bengalis richly deserve and need.

I feel that West Bengal has experimented enough with  Mamata Banerjee’s  Chief MInistership and should give way to another  leader as Chief Minister, who may have possibly a different approach . 

Possibly, the next Chief Minister of West Bengal should follow  the example set by   Naveen Patnaik , the Chief Minister of the neighbouring state Odisha, for  the bench mark  that he has created for dignified governance.

I do not suggest which should be other political party that should come to power in West Bengal  after the election,  but certainly West Bengal needs a different Chief Minister .

 West Bengal cannot afford another five years of the type of leadership that Mamata Banerjee could provide.  

 Can any one reasonabl;y hope that Mamata Banerjee would give a different type of more positive leadership in the next five years than what she has done in the last ten years?  If somebody would entertain such hope, it could end up as  utopian expectation and as  calculated risk.